The past few years in American politics have seen some truly surreal developments, perhaps none more so than the ongoing popularity of Donald Trump in the Republican Party. So what's behind Trump's appeal in the GOP?
Despite being impeached twice and investigated by numerous federal agencies for a variety of crimes, Trump remains a top contender for the GOP in any future presidential election. How can this be? Is it simply that his base is too fanatically devoted to abandon him, or is there something deeper at play?
The paradoxical appeal of Donald Trump in the Republican Party makes me wonder why his misdeeds seem to have little impact on his popularity among conservatives.
Despite a seeming inability to articulate coherent policy positions or demonstrate basic competence in many areas, Trump is an unquestionably skilled orator and entertainer. His rallies are infamous for their raucous crowds and unhinged performances. Still, they are also highly effective at whipping up his base and reinforcing the sense of tribalism that has become such a hallmark of contemporary politics.
For many Republicans, the thrill of being part of a "winning" team that repudiates the so-called "liberal elites" is simply too intoxicating to resist, even in the face of ample evidence that Trump himself is a deeply flawed individual.
Another key factor in Trump's appeal is the widespread belief among his supporters that he is persecuted unfairly by the media and "deep state" operatives. This narrative has taken hold particularly strongly among certain segments of the Republican electorate that feel alienated and disempowered by the modern world.
To these individuals, Trump represents a bulwark against an encroaching liberal order that seeks to strip them of their values, beliefs, and way of life. They see stories about Trump's misdeeds or scandals not as evidence of his unfitness for office, but as further proof of a vast conspiracy against him and his supporters.
There is also a certain degree of racial politics at play in Trump's ongoing appeal. As the original prompt notes, there is a sense that Trump is being held to a different standard than a non-white or non-male politician would be.
So what's behind Trump's appeal in the GO?
This perspective doesn't tell the whole story. For many voters, Trump's unabashedly nativist and xenophobic rhetoric is itself a key part of his appeal. His attacks on immigrants, Muslims, and other marginalized groups allow many conservative voters to indulge in a form of white identity politics that is increasingly out of step with mainstream American values, but appears to be alive and well in the Republican Party.
Overall, it's worth noting that the reasons why Trump remains a top candidate for the Republican Party are complex and multifaceted. Some elements of his appeal (such as his skill as an entertainer or his ability to rally up his base) might be seen as relatively benign or even positive qualities for a political leader. Others, however, (such as the conspiratorial thinking and racial politics that underlie so much of his message) are deeply troubling and suggest that the Republican Party as a whole is struggling to grapple with the challenges of modern politics.
Whatever happens in future elections, it's clear that the draw of Donald Trump will continue to be a major force in American politics for some time to come.
Donald Trump's paradoxical appeal to the Republican Party is complex and multifaceted. His skill as a political performer, the widespread belief among his supporters that he is being persecuted unfairly, and the racial politics inherent in his message are all factors that help explain why Trump remains such a potent force in contemporary American politics.
Whether or not this appeal is a good thing for the country remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: we ignore Donald Trump and his supporters at our peril. It's up to all of us, regardless of our political beliefs, to examine this phenomenon with clear eyes and come to a better understanding of where we stand as a nation.
Dr. Pamela Gurley is a Content Strategy Expert, International Speaker, World-Renowned Best-Selling Author, and Journalist who understands the power of words (both verbal and written). As the Founder/CEO of Clark and Hill Enterprise and IAMDRPGURLEY and Founder/President of the Brown Girl and Brown Boy Literacy Foundation, she is on a mission to empower, grow, transform, and motivate others, as well as lead and challenge social norms and false narratives.